
The origins of the school lay in the efforts of the American Missionary Association (AMA) and the Freedman's Bureau to educate blacks following emancipation. In 1867, representatives of the AMA selected Marion as the site and worked with local residents, including nine formerly enslaved men, to raise the necessary funds. One of the men, Alexander Curtis, took the lead in establishing the institution as a normal school, which would provide teacher training in addition to a regular curriculum, but this goal would not be realized for a number of years. The school followed the model of a typical educational institution of the time, filing a charter and incorporating, on July 18, 1867. There is a widely circulating legend that the school's origins lie with a Union soldier who taught local black children as he was recovering from wounds sustained in the Civil War, but there is no hard evidence to support this claim.

Under Card's guidance, the school reorganized in 1874 as the State Normal School for Colored Students in Marion and expanded to include a teacher-training program while still carrying on its primary education mission. In late 1886, a group of local whites petitioned to have the school removed after an altercation between white students from Howard College and Black Lincoln students. In the petition, the group complained that the school was dissuading prospective white students from coming to Marion. Some Black residents responded by boycotting white businesses. The petition was received favorably by the legislature, which agreed in 1887 to fund an African American college or university somewhere other than Marion. Booker T. Washington, who had just opened Tuskegee Normal Industrial School in 1881, opposed locating it in Montgomery as too close to Tuskegee, Macon County, preferring that it be located in Birmingham. Other options included Brewton, Mobile, and Selma. Notably in Birmingham and Selma, white residents voiced opposition to locating a Black normal school in those cities and were heeded.
Ultimately, the school's trustees chose Montgomery, and the last Marion class graduated in June 1888. The Marion school was split, and the teacher-training component moved to Montgomery and became the Alabama Colored People's University. This school would evolve into present-day Alabama State University. The legislature forbid another normal school on the land vacated in Marion but did allow for a regular public school. Meanwhile, Howard, which was experiencing falling enrollments, was moved in 1887 to Birmingham to take advantage of that city's economic growth. It would become Samford University. Howard president Col. James T. Murfee stayed in Marion with a small group of faculty who together formed a new college for young men, Marion Military Institute.

By the time that Phillips died in 1927, the school had expanded to nearly 600 students, 26 teachers, 11 buildings serving various functions, and 40 acres of land that included a farm. Two dormitories housed students who did not live within easy daily travel distance from the school. In 1939, the school dedicated its newly finished auditorium to Phillips.

In 1954, the U.S. Supreme Court declared segregation in public schools unconstitutional in the Brown v. Board of Education case, resulting in the eventual closing of Lincoln and other segregated schools. In 1960, the AMA severed its remaining ties with the school, and the state took over full operation. Lincoln celebrated its 100th anniversary in 1967 and graduated its final high school class in 1969 and its final sixth-grade class in 1970, when it ceased operations. The school's alumni association remains active and celebrates the school's importance to African Americans in Marion for more than 100 years. The association has preserved one of the school's original buildings and now owns the 22 acres of the original school campus. On July 19, 2019, 100 ASU freshmen made a pilgrimage to the Lincoln Normal School campus and participated in a ceremony to celebrate the school's heritage.
Additional Resources
Caver, Joseph. From Marion to Montgomery: The Early Years of Alabama State University, 1867-1925. Montgomery, Ala.: New South Books, 2020.
Additional Resources
Caver, Joseph. From Marion to Montgomery: The Early Years of Alabama State University, 1867-1925. Montgomery, Ala.: New South Books, 2020.
Richardson, Joe M., and Maxine D. Jones. Education for Liberation: The American Missionary Association and African Americans, 1890 to the Civil Rights Movement. Tuscaloosa: University of Alabama Press, 2009.
Sherer, Robert G. Black Education in Alabama, 1865-1901. Tuscaloosa, Ala.: University of Alabama Press, 1997.